To name but a few, we see nail polishes with “magnetic, gel, matte, glitter, crackle, stamping, quick-dry, caviar, sponge, color changing, leather and sandy” effects. There are also nail polishes with kale, silk and nylon extracts! It really has turned into an art form.
However, in order for us to appreciate the wonders of these magical nail polishes, surely there must be some exciting science behind it all? Many may have wondered and been fascinated by these different effects and thought it would be a good idea to finally look into why stamping polish “stamps”, why crackle polish “crackles” and why UV nail polish “cures”…
Different types of gel polishes cure differently
Believe it or not, there are varying degrees of curing gel polishes; those that are displayed in your local retailer as ‘daylight curing’ polish, those ‘hybrid’ gels that can be bought from your local shopping centre and then, of course, those ‘soak-off’ gels in potted jars found only in your local beauticians! Both the hybrid and soak-off gels require the use of a “UV lamp” to cure. The difference being that the hybrid gels incorporate similar solvents and additives as regular nail polish, allowing them to soak off faster and possess a lower viscosity for easier application. Traditional gels have a higher degree of cross-linking, resulting in a greater resistance to acetone .
How to study curing behavior
The Kinexus rheometer was used to study different-colored UV-curing nail gels (of the potted, soak-off variety) in the shades of gold glitter, red, pink and black. By applying a fixed intensity of UV light to the gels for 30 seconds, it is possible to monitor the curing profile and consequently the change in modulus(stiffness) in these materials over time. Distinct differences were seen between gels with different pigments (see figure 1). The clear gel with gold glitter particles cured the fastest of all four gels, exhibiting a much higher modulus (~7.5 x 107 Pa) in comparison to the black gel, which cured slower resulting in a much lower shear modulus (~3.7 x 105 Pa).
This result was confirmed by conducting a post-cure amplitude sweep on the gels. This measurement probed the linear viscoelastic region (Linear Viscoelastic Region (LVER)In the LVER, applied stresses are insufficient to cause structural breakdown (yielding) of the structure and hence important micro-structural properties are being measured.LVER) of the samples by applying an increasing StrainStrain describes a deformation of a material, which is loaded mechanically by an external force or stress. Rubber compounds show creep properties, if a static load is applied.strain and determining the point at which the structure in the material was broken down – the onset of non-linearity. Figure 2 shows the results from this experiment and it can be clearly seen that the black gel has a longer LVER than the glitter gel.
How to interpret the results
Based on the results, it can be said that the black gel will be more flexible on the nail and is more likely to be easily removed. Due to the smaller (in strain magnitude) linear viscoelastic region, the glitter gel will exhibit more brittle properties and may also be harder to remove. It is instances like these where rheology can be employed as a useful tool in determining differences and characterizing products that will be noticeable and important to consumers.
This blog has focused on curing nail polish and the influence of pigment. However, the rheology of nail polishes builds up a picture of how the material behaves in use. Just like paints, nail polishes exhibit thixotropic properties – the properties that most importantly give you that nice smooth and even surface finish.